When Fraud Strikes the Hobby: Lessons from the Mancave Bust & What It Means for Reclaim Customs

In mid-2025, the collectibles and autograph community was jolted awake by one of the biggest fraud scandals we’ve seen in decades. The Indiana raid and confession surrounding Mister Mancave / Brett Lemieux has rippled through the hobby like a shockwave. For companies like Reclaim Customs, it’s more than cautionary — it’s a call to double down on trust, transparency, and integrity.

Below, I’ll outline what we know about the scandal, how it undermines confidence in the market, and why our updated policies and standards are critical in restoring faith with collectors.

The Mancave Scandal: What Actually Happened

Allegations, raid, and confession

• Authorities in Westfield, Indiana executed raids in July 2025 on locations tied to Mister Mancave LLC, a business run by Brett Lemieux. CBSSports.com+3Sports Collectors Daily+3Otia Sports+3

• During the raid, law enforcement discovered extensive memorabilia, documentation, hologram equipment, and evidence of large-scale operations. Antique Trader+4Sports Collectors Digest+4Otia Sports+4

• Tragically, Lemieux was found deceased at one of the sites, believed to have died by an apparent self-inflicted gunshot wound. Cardlines+4Sports Collectors Digest+4Otia Sports+4

• Shortly before his death, he posted a long confession in the “Autographs 101” Facebook group, admitting to forging autographs, crafting fake holograms, and selling over 4 million counterfeit items over the span of ~20 years — claiming more than $350 million in fraudulent sales. Sports Collectors Daily+5Beckett+5Antique Trader+5

• Among his claims: fabrication of counterfeit authentication stickers (mimicking Panini, Fanatics, JSA, and others) and “bootleg holograms” used to fool collectors into thinking items had credible COAs. CBSSports.com+4Otia Sports+4upperdeckexquisite.com+4

• Some insiders question whether all of Lemieux’s numbers are accurate (for instance, one dealer called the $350M figure “impossible”), but regardless of exact scale, the implications are already being felt. Otia Sports+4Cllct+4Cardlines+4

• 
  

Industry reaction & the damage done

• The bust has revived comparisons to Operation Bullpen, the FBI crackdown on forgeries in the 1990s/2000s, which is still referenced in hobby circles today. upperdeckexquisite.com+3Wikipedia+3Sports Collectors Digest+3

• Experts are warning that many items now in circulation — jerseys, cards, baseballs — may have suspect provenance or fake COAs, meaning collectors will need to scrutinize like never before. Sports Collectors Digest+2Otia Sports+2

• Dealers and authenticators are publicly expressing shock and concern about how long the alleged operation persisted without detection — and whether the ripple effect will damage confidence in autograph/memorabilia markets broadly. Sports Collectors Digest+2Otia Sports+2

• Some collectors who believed they had genuine items from big names (Kobe Bryant, Tom Brady, Patrick Mahomes, etc.) are now re-examining their collections and questioning whether they were duped. Cardlines+4upperdeckexquisite.com+4Otia Sports+4

• The scandal underscores a critical reality: a convincing COA or hologram is not enough on its own. The chain of custody, context, and independent verification now matter more than ever.

• 
  

What This Means for Reclaim Customs & Collectors

As a company working directly in the space of custom autographed or relic-enhanced memorabilia, this scandal strikes to the heart of our mission. If trust breaks down, the whole structure collapses. So here’s how we see the risks — and how we’re defending against them.

1. Trust is fragile — and must be actively protected

Collectors are going to get more wary, more cautious. A single headline like this can make someone pause before buying an autograph. We must continually earn (and re-earn) credibility.

This means that even if we have done everything “by the book,” perception matters. Any ambiguity in provenance or authentication can erode trust.

2. Our updated policies: clarity, rigor, and accountability

In light of the Mancave fallout, we've updated and reinforced our internal policies to ensure we remain a fortress of integrity. Here is what we’re committing to:

• Authentication only by trusted services — PSA, JSA, Beckett, or G.O.A.T.We will continue to require that any autograph we handle must be backed by one of those authenticators, either via sticker, certificate, or documented opinion. This remains the core of our legitimacy framework.

• No unauthorized third-party sticker useWe will not embed, replicate, or incorporate external authentication stickers, labels, holograms, or seals into any design unless we have a formal, verified partnership with the authentication entity in question. If an autograph is cracked from a slab or detached from its original sticker, its validity is voided in our process.

• Discretionary re-evaluation / re-authenticationIf we or the customer has doubts about the legitimacy of an autograph or COA, we reserve the right to send it for additional evaluation by a third-party authenticator we approve. Transparency is key — we’ll document that process for clients.

• Support for re-authenticationIf customers want their completed piece (or their original autograph) re-authenticated, we’ll guide them through the process: how to submit to the authenticator, best practices, timeline expectations, etc.

• Zero tolerance for suspicious COAsIf a COA looks questionable — faint hologram, poor printing, inconsistent numbering, non-matching database records — we won’t just press forward. It will be flagged and re-checked before any work is approved or shipped.

• Our GOAT Authentics collaborationOur existing partnership/integration with GOAT Authentics (for Jordan, Gretzky, Brady) is a pillar in our verification process. Even if someone previously authenticated a piece using another service, we still run checks and cross-reference procedures through GOAT to detect anomalies or red flags.

These steps aren’t just for show — they’re essential guardrails in a marketplace now shaken by the worst kind of deception.

3. Educating customers & raising awareness

It’s not enough to be rigorous internally — we also need to empower collectors. That’s why going forward, we plan to:

• Publish resources (guides, checklists, red flags) so collectors can better evaluate autographed items themselves.

• Transparently show our process: what steps we take, which authenticators we trust, how we document provenance.

• Encourage open dialogue: if customers have suspicions about a piece (before or after purchase), we’ll work with them to investigate.

• Use clear labeling: “authenticated by [service name], submitted on [date], certificate ID [ID]” — no vague claims.

When customers see that kind of transparency, they gain confidence. And that confidence is what separates legitimate operations from the fraudsters.

Why This Matters for the Hobby’s Future

The Mancave bust is a major turning point for the sports collectibles world. It brings to light vulnerabilities that many suspected but few expected to see exposed so thoroughly. The long-term damage will depend on whether the hobby's institutions respond — how strongly dealers, authenticators, distributors, and creators like us push back against lax standards.

For Reclaim Customs, this moment is a chance to lean into integrity rather than hide. Collectors need safe harbors more than ever. By being transparent, unwavering, and customer-first, we position ourselves not just as a vendor, but as a trusted steward of memory, legacy, and authenticity.